A client says in the middle of the meeting that your proposal is worthless.
Take this situation apart. Each piece goes in one box: yours, or not yours. There is no third box, and almost nothing falls in one piece.
Sort it yourself first. Each piece goes in one box; the reasoning follows your choice.
Whether you acknowledge what is fair before disputing what is not.
Yours. This piece is almost always skipped, because it feels like retreating. It is the opposite: acknowledge the true part at once and you get a hearing for the rest.
Whether the others at the table side with him.
Not yours. Six heads with six considerations you cannot reach. Agreement proves nothing about the quality of your proposal, only something about the dynamic in that room.
That he said it with the whole table listening.
Not yours. His choice of moment and audience. Unpleasant, and entirely outside your power once the sentence had been spoken.
Whether he signs in the end.
Not yours. The signature was never yours. What was yours was the quality of the proposal and the way you defended it, and that stays true if he says no.
Whether you are still angry tonight about the way he said it.
Yours. The manner was his, the dragging along is yours. Anyone who takes the tone home holds the meeting a second time, now without an opponent.
Whether you start defending immediately or ask a question first.
Yours. Defending is a reflex, asking is a choice. One question about what exactly is wrong almost always yields more than three sentences explaining yourself.
Yours
- Whether you start defending immediately or ask a question first.Defending is a reflex, asking is a choice. One question about what exactly is wrong almost always yields more than three sentences explaining yourself.
- Whether you are still angry tonight about the way he said it.The manner was his, the dragging along is yours. Anyone who takes the tone home holds the meeting a second time, now without an opponent.
- Whether you acknowledge what is fair before disputing what is not.This piece is almost always skipped, because it feels like retreating. It is the opposite: acknowledge the true part at once and you get a hearing for the rest.
Not yours
- That he said it with the whole table listening.His choice of moment and audience. Unpleasant, and entirely outside your power once the sentence had been spoken.
- Whether the others at the table side with him.Six heads with six considerations you cannot reach. Agreement proves nothing about the quality of your proposal, only something about the dynamic in that room.
- Whether he signs in the end.The signature was never yours. What was yours was the quality of the proposal and the way you defended it, and that stays true if he says no.
The reasoning. Criticism in public feels like one event, but three layers are folded into it: the content, the manner and the audience. Only the content touches your work. The manner says something about him and the audience says something about the room. Hold those apart and you can learn from the criticism and leave the insult lying in the same minute.
- It is not things themselves that disturb people, but their opinions about things.Epictetus · Enchiridion 5
Nearby situations
Your presentation lands badly with the room.Criticism and insultA devastating comment appears under your work online.Criticism and insultYour appraisal contains something you did not see coming.Criticism and insult
More on this topic: Criticism and insult · How to stop caring what people think