A devastating comment appears under your work online.

Take this situation apart. Each piece goes in one box: yours, or not yours. There is no third box, and almost nothing falls in one piece.

Sort it yourself first. Each piece goes in one box; the reasoning follows your choice.

That the comment is there.
Not yours. Somebody typed and pressed send. That is a fact in the outside world, like rain. You can report it or ignore it, but you cannot unmake it.
Whether you go back and read it a fifth time.
Yours. Reading it the first time happened to you. The fifth time is an act, and it is the act that keeps the sting alive.
Whether you take out what is usable and leave the rest.
Yours. Most people stumble here, because criticism feels like one indivisible block. It is not. Whether there is something true in it is not yours, but whether you extract that truth is, and those two are almost always confused.
That the tone is harsher than it needed to be.
Not yours. His manners, his day, his upbringing. The harshness says something about the writer and nothing about the quality of your work.
Whether you reply, and in what tone.
Yours. Entirely yours, and the only sentence in this whole story that will carry your name. Write it as though you will read it back in a year.
What other readers make of it.
Not yours. A hundred people read along and form a hundred judgments you are not present for. Anyone who tries to steer this box is busy for the rest of his life.
Skip and show the cut
Yours
  • Whether you go back and read it a fifth time.Reading it the first time happened to you. The fifth time is an act, and it is the act that keeps the sting alive.
  • Whether you take out what is usable and leave the rest.Most people stumble here, because criticism feels like one indivisible block. It is not. Whether there is something true in it is not yours, but whether you extract that truth is, and those two are almost always confused.
  • Whether you reply, and in what tone.Entirely yours, and the only sentence in this whole story that will carry your name. Write it as though you will read it back in a year.
Not yours
  • That the comment is there.Somebody typed and pressed send. That is a fact in the outside world, like rain. You can report it or ignore it, but you cannot unmake it.
  • What other readers make of it.A hundred people read along and form a hundred judgments you are not present for. Anyone who tries to steer this box is busy for the rest of his life.
  • That the tone is harsher than it needed to be.His manners, his day, his upbringing. The harshness says something about the writer and nothing about the quality of your work.
The reasoning. Criticism arrives as one lump and leaves as six pieces. Notice the proportion: three of the six are yours, and they are exactly the three that decide how you stand a week from now. The lump feels bigger than it is because the tone and the audience get mixed in with the content. Separate those and what usually remains is one usable sentence and a great deal of noise.

Nearby situations

More on this topic: Criticism and insult · How to stop caring what people think

Yours, Not Yours · A Stoic practice ground · Learn · Videos · About this site · Privacy · Questions or suggestions

Free, no ads · Support with a few euros · Where it goes