In your performance review you get criticism of which half is accurate and half is not.
Take this situation apart. Each piece goes in one box: yours, or not yours. There is no third box, and almost nothing falls in one piece.
Sort it yourself first. Each piece goes in one box; the reasoning follows your choice.
The part that is not accurate.
Not yours. That says something about the reviewer’s eye, his yardstick or his day, and none of the three is yours. You do not have to refute it in order not to take it home.
The tone in which you respond, including to the inaccurate part.
Yours. Precisely with the part that is not accurate, your tone gets read as evidence. Whoever stays calm at an unfair reproach makes the unfairness visible; whoever explodes hands it its proof after all. Your tone is the one argument you deliver without words.
The part of the criticism that is accurate.
Yours. That part is a gift, however it was wrapped: you can use it tomorrow. Sorting is done per sentence, not per conversation; otherwise you swallow everything or reject everything.
Yours
- The part of the criticism that is accurate.That part is a gift, however it was wrapped: you can use it tomorrow. Sorting is done per sentence, not per conversation; otherwise you swallow everything or reject everything.
- The tone in which you respond, including to the inaccurate part.Precisely with the part that is not accurate, your tone gets read as evidence. Whoever stays calm at an unfair reproach makes the unfairness visible; whoever explodes hands it its proof after all. Your tone is the one argument you deliver without words.
Not yours
- The part that is not accurate.That says something about the reviewer’s eye, his yardstick or his day, and none of the three is yours. You do not have to refute it in order not to take it home.
The reasoning. Half right is no reason to accept everything or reject everything; it is a reason to sort.
- He who changes his mind and follows a just correction is no less free.after Marcus Aurelius · Meditations 8.16
Nearby situations
In a meeting your idea is credited to someone else.Criticism and insultIn your performance review you get a criticism you disagree with.Criticism and insultSomeone is spreading a story about you that is demonstrably untrue.Criticism and insult
More on this topic: Criticism and insult · How to stop caring what people think