Home › Situations › Criticism and insult

In your performance review you get a criticism you disagree with.

Take this situation apart. Each piece goes in one box: yours, or not yours. There is no third box, and almost nothing falls in one piece.

Sort it yourself first. Each piece goes in one box; the reasoning follows your choice.

Calmly asking for examples and giving your side.
Yours. Asking for specifics, testing whether there is something in it, giving your own reading without shifting into combat: that is your half of the conversation, and the only half you can prepare.
Your manager’s judgment.
Not yours. Whether he comes around, and what stays in his assessment, is decided by him. One criticism is an observation about this year’s work, not a statement about you as a person.
What ends up in the written record.
Not yours. The record is the administration of his judgment, and he holds that pen. Your reply may end up in it or not; that decision falls on his side of the desk. You only sign for what you said and how.
Skip and show the cut
Yours
  • Calmly asking for examples and giving your side.Asking for specifics, testing whether there is something in it, giving your own reading without shifting into combat: that is your half of the conversation, and the only half you can prepare.
Not yours
  • Your manager’s judgment.Whether he comes around, and what stays in his assessment, is decided by him. One criticism is an observation about this year’s work, not a statement about you as a person.
  • What ends up in the written record.The record is the administration of his judgment, and he holds that pen. Your reply may end up in it or not; that decision falls on his side of the desk. You only sign for what you said and how.
The reasoning. Take what is accurate, leave what is not, and let the conversation end where the conversation ends.

Watch in a minute

Got criticised? That doesn’t mean you failedUnder a minute

All short videos, with the text · YouTube

Practise this situation

Nearby situations

Someone is spreading a story about you that is demonstrably untrue.Criticism and insultA stream of negative reactions appears under your post.Criticism and insultYou get a bad review from a customer who only half understood it.Criticism and insult

More on this topic: Criticism and insult · How to stop caring what people think

Yours, Not Yours · A Stoic practice ground · Learn · Videos · About this site · Questions or suggestions

Free, no ads · Support with a few euros