Short video · Criticism and insult

Got criticised? Two things arrive at once

Someone criticises your work and it feels like a verdict on you. This short video separates the remark from the verdict.

Answer first, then watch. Skip to the video

Criticism means you failed.
Right: false.Not quite: false. Criticism has two parts that arrive together and feel like one. There is information: this paragraph is unclear, this deadline was missed, this number is wrong. And there is a sting: the sense that you have been weighed and found wanting. The information may be useful. The sting is something you add, in the moment of reading.

Watch the video

33 seconds · English · Watch on YouTube

The sorting

Yours
  • Whether there is something useful in it
  • What you do with that
  • Whether you turn it into a verdict on yourself
Not yours
  • Their opinion of your work
  • Their words, their taste, their timing
  • Whether they say it kindly

What the video says

Criticism means you failed. True or false? False. It means someone has an opinion about your work.

Their words, their taste, their timing: that is not yours. What is yours? Whether there is something useful in it, and what you do with it.

Epictetus said it almost 2,000 years ago: we are not disturbed by things, but by the opinions we hold about them. So take what is useful, and leave the sting.

Yours, not yours. Practise for free at yoursnotyours.com.

Beyond the video

Criticism has two parts that arrive together and feel like one. There is information: this paragraph is unclear, this deadline was missed, this number is wrong. And there is a sting: the sense that you have been weighed and found wanting. The information may be useful. The sting is something you add, in the moment of reading.

Separating the two takes practice, because the sting comes first and loudest. A useful habit is to read or hear the criticism twice. The first time, let it sting; that first movement is not yours to stop. The second time, read it as if it were about someone else’s work, and keep only what would help that person improve.

The source

Keep practising

More short videos

Yours, Not Yours · A Stoic practice ground · Learn · Videos · About this site · Privacy · Questions or suggestions

Free, no ads · Support with a few euros · Where it goes