Your appraisal contains something you did not see coming.
Take this situation apart. Each piece goes in one box: yours, or not yours. There is no third box, and almost nothing falls in one piece.
Sort it yourself first. Each piece goes in one box; the reasoning follows your choice.
Whether you ask for an example instead of disputing the label.
Yours. A label cannot be refuted, an example can be discussed. That question is yours and it turns the meeting from defending into investigating.
Whether you have done something with it three months from now.
Yours. That is the only lasting answer. Anyone doing something differently a quarter later has used the criticism rather than processed it.
Whether it stays in your file.
Not yours. Paper, procedure, somebody else's pen. You can respond and you cannot erase it.
Whether you take it as information or as an assault.
Yours. Here is the whole cut. The same sentence can be a verdict on your worth or an observation about your work, and which of the two you make of it is yours.
That it appeared in the report without warning.
Not yours. His way of working. It could have come earlier and it did not, and that cannot be moved now.
Whether others think the same of you.
Not yours. One opinion is not a survey. You cannot determine what sits in other people's heads, and you can go and ask.
Yours
- Whether you ask for an example instead of disputing the label.A label cannot be refuted, an example can be discussed. That question is yours and it turns the meeting from defending into investigating.
- Whether you take it as information or as an assault.Here is the whole cut. The same sentence can be a verdict on your worth or an observation about your work, and which of the two you make of it is yours.
- Whether you have done something with it three months from now.That is the only lasting answer. Anyone doing something differently a quarter later has used the criticism rather than processed it.
Not yours
- That it appeared in the report without warning.His way of working. It could have come earlier and it did not, and that cannot be moved now.
- Whether others think the same of you.One opinion is not a survey. You cannot determine what sits in other people's heads, and you can go and ask.
- Whether it stays in your file.Paper, procedure, somebody else's pen. You can respond and you cannot erase it.
The reasoning. With criticism from above people mix two questions: is it true, and should it have been handled this way. The second belongs under Not yours and yields only irritation. The first belongs under Yours and is the only one that takes you anywhere. Ask for an example and within two minutes you know which column this remark belongs in.
- If anyone can show me that I think or act wrongly, I will gladly change.Marcus Aurelius · Meditations 6.21
Nearby situations
In your performance review you get criticism of which half is accurate and half is not.Criticism and insultIn a meeting your idea is credited to someone else.Criticism and insultIn your performance review you get a criticism you disagree with.Criticism and insult
More on this topic: Criticism and insult · How to stop caring what people think