How to stop overthinking

You cannot stop a thought by ordering it to stop, and trying makes it louder. What works is one question, asked every time the loop starts: is there anything in this for me to do? If there is, do it or plan it. If there is not, the thought is about something that is not yours, and you may leave it where it is.

Sort the thought yourself

Take an evening like this one. It comes apart into six pieces. Sort each piece before you read on.

You sent an important message this morning and there is still no reply. Tonight your head will not leave it alone.

Sort it yourself first. Each piece goes in one box; the reasoning follows your choice.

What the other person thinks of your message.
Not yours. That is being formed, or not, in a head you cannot open. Every scenario you write tonight is your own writing.
The jolt when the thought comes up again.
Not yours. It presents itself without asking. Seneca calls this the first movement and says plainly that it is not in our power.
Whether you go round once more or put it down.
Yours. After the jolt comes a small choice: follow the thought, or note that there is nothing new in it. You make that choice many times in an evening, and each time it is yours.
Whether you decide now to send one short follow up tomorrow at ten.
Yours. This is the one action hiding in the loop. Decide it, put a time on it, and the loop has nothing left to prepare.
When the reply comes, and whether it comes.
Not yours. Their diary, their mood and their inbox decide that. Refreshing yours does not speed it up.
What you take from it for the next message you write.
Yours. Looking back once, for a lesson, is yours and takes two minutes. Looking back for the tenth time is the same two minutes, repeated.
Skip and show the cut
Yours
  • Whether you decide now to send one short follow up tomorrow at ten.This is the one action hiding in the loop. Decide it, put a time on it, and the loop has nothing left to prepare.
  • What you take from it for the next message you write.Looking back once, for a lesson, is yours and takes two minutes. Looking back for the tenth time is the same two minutes, repeated.
  • Whether you go round once more or put it down.After the jolt comes a small choice: follow the thought, or note that there is nothing new in it. You make that choice many times in an evening, and each time it is yours.
Not yours
  • What the other person thinks of your message.That is being formed, or not, in a head you cannot open. Every scenario you write tonight is your own writing.
  • When the reply comes, and whether it comes.Their diary, their mood and their inbox decide that. Refreshing yours does not speed it up.
  • The jolt when the thought comes up again.It presents itself without asking. Seneca calls this the first movement and says plainly that it is not in our power.
The reasoning. Three pieces belong to another person or arrive unasked, and no amount of thinking reaches them. Three are small acts: one follow up, one lesson, one decision to stop the lap. Overthinking is what happens when the first three get the attention the last three needed.

Why can you not just stop thinking about it?

The first thought arrives by itself. You did not order it, and the Stoics never blamed anyone for that: Seneca calls it the first movement of the mind and says it is not in our power. The trouble starts one step later, when you follow it.

Thinking and overthinking look alike but end differently. Thinking finishes: in a decision, a plan, a changed view. Overthinking returns to the same point with the same information. Each lap feels like preparation, which is why stopping feels careless. But nothing changed between lap three and lap thirty.

So the way out is not to stop thinking. It is to finish the thought: to decide what in it, if anything, is yours to do.

What did the Stoics say about worrying?

Seneca wrote a whole letter about it to his friend Lucilius:

His advice in that letter is practical. Ask whether the trouble is certain. Ask whether it is here yet. Most of the time the honest answers are no and no, and what remains is a picture you made yourself. Marcus Aurelius, who had an empire to worry about, wrote the same thing down for his own use:

None of this tells you to feel calm. It tells you to look. A worry that has been looked at is usually smaller and more specific than it was while it circled.

Four things to do when the loop starts

  1. Write the thought down as one sentence. A loop lives on vagueness. On paper, everything is going wrong becomes I do not know whether the client will renew, and that is a sentence you can work with.
  2. Ask the sorting question. Is there something in this for me to do? Not: is it important. It nearly always is. Only: is there a move, and is it mine?
  3. If yes, make it small and give it a time. Call her at nine ends a loop. Sort things out starts a new one.
  4. If no, say so in words. This one is not mine. Marcus Aurelius told himself to confine himself to the present (Meditations 7.29). The thought will come back, and you say it again. It is practice, not a switch.

How do you stop overthinking at night?

Night is the worst time to sort, because nothing can be done before morning and your mind knows it. Every item looks unsolvable at three, including the ones that take five minutes at nine.

Keep paper next to the bed. Write the one sentence, and under it the first step with a time: tomorrow, nine, call. From that moment the matter is not yours until nine. Seneca has a line for the hours in between: he who suffers before it is necessary suffers more than is necessary (Letter 98).

This will not always make you sleep. Sleep is not fully yours either. But lying awake without arguing is a better night than lying awake in court.

The honest objection

Is this not just a clever way of saying: stop worrying? No, and the difference matters. A good half of what keeps people busy does contain something to do, and the method insists that you do it. Planning is thinking with an ending. Only what is left after that goes in the other box.

Practise it on real situations

Reading this once changes little. The sorting has to become quick, and that takes repetition. These situations are worked out piece by piece, and you can sort each one yourself first.

The topic The inner world has all the exercises on this theme. If you want the background to Seneca's line, see what he actually wrote in Letter 13, and if you would rather sort on paper, the circle of control has a worksheet.

Questions people ask

How do I stop overthinking?

Not by willpower, because pushing a thought away keeps it in view. The Stoic method is to sort the thought: is there an action in it that is yours? If so, take it or give it a time. If not, it concerns the past, the future or what goes on in someone else's head, none of which you control, and the thinking can end there.

Why do I overthink everything?

Usually because the mind treats thinking as a way of getting control. Each new lap feels like preparation, so stopping feels careless. The Stoic test is to check what the lap produced: a decision, a step, a lesson. If it produced none of these, more of the same will not either, and the subject probably lies outside what you control.

How do I stop thinking about something that is bothering me?

Do not try to push it out, because that keeps it in view. Write it down as one sentence, decide whether there is anything in it for you to do, and either plan that step or say plainly that the matter is not yours. Then give your attention a job: something with your hands, or a task with an end.

What did Seneca say about worrying?

In Letter 13 to Lucilius he writes that more things frighten us than crush us, and that we suffer more often in imagination than in reality. His advice is to ask whether the trouble is certain and whether it is here yet, and not to be unhappy before the time comes.

Is overthinking the same as thinking deeply?

No. Thinking moves: it ends in a decision, a plan or a changed view. Overthinking comes back to the same point with the same information. A quick test is to ask what the last ten minutes produced. If the answer is nothing new, you were circling.

Other questions

SourcesSeneca, Letter 13 to Lucilius (the quotation is from 13.4), Letter 98.8, On Anger 2.4. Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 7.8, 7.29 and 8.47.

Yours, Not Yours · A Stoic practice ground · Learn · Videos · About this site · Privacy · Questions or suggestions

Free, no ads · Support with a few euros · Where it goes