How to control your emotions

You cannot control the first flash: the heat in your face, the drop in your stomach. The Stoics said so themselves. What you can decide is the step after it: whether you agree with what the feeling claims, and what you do. That step is short, and it can be trained.

Sort it yourself

Take a moment at work. It comes apart into six pieces. Sort each piece before you read on.

In a meeting a colleague cuts you off for the third time, and you feel the anger rise.

Sort it yourself first. Each piece goes in one box; the reasoning follows your choice.

The thought: he does this to make me look small.
Yours. This is a judgment, and it came in so fast that it felt like a fact. Perhaps he does it to everyone. Perhaps he is nervous. You are allowed to check before you sign.
That he interrupts you.
Not yours. It is his behaviour. You can raise it with him. You cannot make it not have happened.
What you say to him afterwards, and how.
Yours. Calmly, precisely, with nobody else there: next time I would like to finish my point. That sentence is entirely yours, and it works better without the heat.
Whether you reply within the next two seconds.
Yours. The greatest remedy for anger is delay, Seneca wrote. Two seconds is a delay. So is a sip of water.
The heat that shoots up in you.
Not yours. This is the first movement. It is there before you have decided anything, and Seneca says in so many words that it is not in our power.
What the others at the table make of it.
Not yours. They have their own view of him and of you, and it is formed in their heads.
Skip and show the cut
Yours
  • The thought: he does this to make me look small.This is a judgment, and it came in so fast that it felt like a fact. Perhaps he does it to everyone. Perhaps he is nervous. You are allowed to check before you sign.
  • Whether you reply within the next two seconds.The greatest remedy for anger is delay, Seneca wrote. Two seconds is a delay. So is a sip of water.
  • What you say to him afterwards, and how.Calmly, precisely, with nobody else there: next time I would like to finish my point. That sentence is entirely yours, and it works better without the heat.
Not yours
  • That he interrupts you.It is his behaviour. You can raise it with him. You cannot make it not have happened.
  • The heat that shoots up in you.This is the first movement. It is there before you have decided anything, and Seneca says in so many words that it is not in our power.
  • What the others at the table make of it.They have their own view of him and of you, and it is formed in their heads.
The reasoning. The interruption, the first heat and the audience are not yours. The verdict, the pause and the sentence you choose are. Controlling your emotions turns out to mean controlling three small things that are not emotions at all.

Can you actually control your emotions?

Not the beginning of them. Seneca is plain about it: the first movement of the mind is not within our power (On Anger 2.4). He compares it to blinking when something flies at your face.

There is an old story that makes the point. The Roman writer Aulus Gellius was on a ship in a storm, together with a Stoic philosopher, and saw the man turn as pale as everyone else. Afterwards he asked him about it. The philosopher took a book of Epictetus from his bag and showed him the passage: impressions strike the mind before it can decide anything, and even a wise person is moved for a moment. The difference is that he does not go on to agree that something terrible is happening (Attic Nights 19.1).

So if you have been blaming yourself for feeling anger, fear or envy at all, the Stoics would say you are blaming yourself for the weather.

What is yours, then?

Between the flash and what you do next sits a judgment. He did that on purpose. I cannot bear this. I need this now. It comes so fast that it feels like something you saw, but it is a claim, and claims can be checked. Epictetus built his whole teaching on it:

When the claim changes, the feeling follows. Not at once, but reliably. That one idea later became the starting point of cognitive behavioural therapy, whose founders named Epictetus as their source; the story is in the case Ellis and the sentence that became therapy.

What did the Stoics say about anger?

Seneca wrote three books on anger, and his main remedy fits in one line:

Epictetus taught his students to speak to the impression directly, before agreeing with it:

And Marcus Aurelius kept a list for the moments he was angry with someone. One item on it: our anger and distress at such things do us more harm than the things themselves (Meditations 11.18). An emperor could have had people punished. He wrote himself reminders instead.

Four things to do

  1. Name the flash, without a verdict. There is anger is more accurate than I am angry with him because. Naming it as an event gives you the half second you need.
  2. Delay. Not for an hour. For one breath, one sip of water, one sentence held back. The remedy of Seneca costs nothing and is nearly always available.
  3. Find the judgment and question it. What did I just conclude? That she meant it, that it is a disaster, that I cannot stand this. Is that established, or did I supply it?
  4. Count your days. Epictetus gives the method himself: do not feed the habit, and keep a tally of the days you were not angry. First every other day, then every third. Whoever reaches thirty days, he says, may offer a sacrifice of thanks (Discourses 2.18). A habit you count is a habit you can see.

The honest objection

Is this not simply suppression? Suppression is feeling something and acting as if you do not. The Stoic method works one step earlier: it examines the judgment, so that the feeling changes at its source. And when the judgment survives the examination, because you really were wronged, or a loss really is a loss, the feeling stays and there is nothing wrong with that.

The Stoics did not want a life without feeling. Epictetus says a person should not be unfeeling like a statue (Discourses 3.2). Seneca says the wise feel their troubles and overcome them (Letter 9). They even had a list of good feelings, with joy at the top. The objection is taken further on the page Criticism of Stoicism.

Practise it on real situations

The pause between flash and reply gets longer with practice. These situations are worked out piece by piece, and you can sort each one yourself first.

The topic The inner world has all the exercises on this theme, and the glossary explains the terms the Stoics used for it, such as first movement and assent.

Questions people ask

How do I control my emotions?

Not by suppressing them. The Stoics separated the first stir of a feeling, which is involuntary, from the judgment that follows, which is yours. You cannot prevent the flash of anger or fear. You can delay, check the judgment behind it (was I really wronged, is this really a disaster?) and choose what you do. The feeling tends to follow the judgment.

Did the Stoics suppress their emotions?

No. That is the everyday meaning of the word stoic, not what the philosophers taught. They held that the first stir of a feeling is involuntary and blameless, and they worked on the judgment that follows it. Epictetus says a person should not be unfeeling like a statue, and Seneca that the wise feel their troubles and overcome them.

How do I control my anger in the moment?

Delay first: Seneca calls delay the greatest remedy for anger, and one breath counts. Then look for the judgment under the anger, usually that someone wronged you on purpose, and ask whether you know that. Decide what to say only after that. The order matters more than the calm.

Why do I get emotional so easily?

The first reaction is not a choice and it differs from person to person, so there is little point in blaming yourself for it. What can change with practice is how quickly you agree with what the feeling claims. Epictetus compared it to a habit: each time you do not feed it, it grows a little weaker.

What is the first movement in Stoicism?

It is the involuntary start of an emotion: the jolt, the blush, the tightening, before any judgment. Seneca describes it in On Anger 2.4 and says it is not in our power. An emotion in the full sense only arises when the mind agrees with the impression, for example that an injury was done and calls for a response.

Other questions

SourcesSeneca, On Anger 2.4 and 2.29, Letter 9.3 to Lucilius. Epictetus, Enchiridion 5, Discourses 2.18.12, 2.18.24 and 3.2.4. Aulus Gellius, Attic Nights 19.1. Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 11.18. Diogenes Laertius, Lives of the Eminent Philosophers 7.116.

Yours, Not Yours · A Stoic practice ground · Learn · Videos · About this site · Privacy · Questions or suggestions

Free, no ads · Support with a few euros · Where it goes