How to forgive yourself
What you did lies in the past, and the past is the one thing nobody can change, you included. What is still yours is smaller and more useful: to see it clearly, to repair what can be repaired, to take the lesson, and to do the next thing well. The Stoics called that enough.
Sort it yourself
Take something you said and cannot take back. It comes apart into six pieces. Sort each piece before you read on.
Months ago you said something to a friend in anger that you cannot take back, and it still stings.
Sort it yourself first. Each piece goes in one box; the reasoning follows your choice.
- Whether you say sorry, plainly and without a defence.An apology that explains itself is a plea. I said this, it was wrong, I am sorry: that is entirely yours to give.
- What you take from it.Not: I am a terrible person. That teaches nothing. But something you can use: I say cruel things when I am tired and cornered, so I will leave the room sooner.
- Whether you put yourself on trial again tonight.The memory will come back by itself. Reopening the case each time is something you do. The review Seneca describes ends with a verdict, and then it closes.
- That you said it.It happened, and no amount of regret reaches back to that evening. This is the hardest piece to put in this box, and the most certain.
- Whether your friend forgives you.You can ask. You cannot decide. An apology is owed whether or not it is accepted, and that is what makes it an apology and not a trade.
- How your friend remembers that evening.That memory belongs to your friend. Your conduct from now on is the only thing you can add to it.
Why is it so hard to forgive yourself?
Because blaming yourself feels like taking responsibility. As long as it still hurts, you seem to be taking the matter seriously, and stopping would feel like getting off lightly. So the case stays open. Every night there is a new hearing, and every night the sentence is the same.
But punishment is not repair. Ten more replays do not make the other person whole, and they do not make you less likely to do it again. Often the opposite: someone who is busy condemning himself has little attention left for the person he hurt.
What is still yours, and what is not?
Seneca divides time into three parts: what was, what is and what will be. The present is short and the future uncertain, he writes, but the past is fixed. It is the one part over which fortune has lost its power, and which nobody can bring back under his control (On the Shortness of Life 10).
That is usually read as a comfort about good memories. It applies just as much to mistakes. What you did is no longer yours to work on. What is yours now is the truth about it, the repair, the lesson and your next act. Guilt is useful for exactly as long as it points at one of those four. After that it is a replay.
How did the Stoics deal with their own mistakes?
Seneca describes his own habit. Every evening, when the lamp was out, he went through the whole day and weighed what he had said and done:
- I hide nothing from myself, I pass over nothing. Why should I be afraid of any of my mistakes, when I can say: see that you do not do that again; this time I forgive you.Seneca, On Anger 3.36
Look at the order. First the truth, with nothing hidden. Then the instruction. Only then the pardon. And it happens daily, so nothing piles up. Marcus Aurelius, whose notebook is full of reminders to himself, allowed himself the same:
- Do not be disgusted, discouraged or dissatisfied if you do not always succeed in acting on the right principles. When you have failed, go back to them.Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 5.9
Epictetus adds a sober note. Can a person be free of faults altogether? No, he says, but he can keep working at not making them (Discourses 4.12). And in his Handbook he sets out three stages: the untrained person blames others for what goes wrong, the beginner blames himself, and the trained person blames neither (Enchiridion 5). Blaming yourself, in other words, is a stage. It is better than blaming everyone else, and it is not where you are meant to stay.
Four things to do
- Say what you did in one plain sentence. Without but, and without always. I shouted at her in front of the children is a fact you can work with. I ruin everything is a mood.
- Repair what can be repaired. Apologise, pay back, put right. If the person is out of reach, do the repair forward: give the same care to someone who is here.
- Take one lesson, small enough to use. A rule for next time is worth more than a verdict on your character.
- Close the session. Use the words of Seneca if you like: see that you do not do it again; this time I forgive you. When the memory comes back, you are not obliged to reopen the case. The lesson stands. The trial is over.
The honest objection
Is this not letting yourself off too easily? It would be, if the pardon came first. In the order Seneca follows it comes last, after you have named what you did and committed to doing better. And it cancels nothing you owe to others: the repair remains. What it ends is the sentence without end, which helps nobody.
A second objection is harder. Some things cannot be repaired, and some people will not forgive. That is true. Your part is then smaller, not gone: tell the truth, carry the lesson, act differently. The Stoics did not promise that it stops hurting. They said the hurt does not have to decide what you do.
Practise it on real situations
Separating what you did from what is still to be done gets easier with practice. These situations are worked out piece by piece, and you can sort each one yourself first.
The topic Work and failure has all the exercises on this theme. If the replaying is the main problem, see how to stop overthinking.
Questions people ask
How do I forgive myself?
Separate what you did from what remains to be done. The deed is past and cannot be changed, so it is no longer yours to work on. Four things are: admitting it without excuse, repairing what can be repaired, taking the lesson, and acting better from now on. Seneca reviewed his faults every evening and closed with: see that you do not do it again; this time I forgive you.
How do I forgive myself for a mistake I cannot fix?
Then the repair that is open to you points forward. Admit plainly what happened, take a lesson you can actually use, and give the care you owe to the people who are here now. The past stays as it is. Your part is what you do with the time after it.
Why can I not stop feeling guilty?
Often because the guilt has become your proof that you care, so ending it feels like not caring. Check whether it still points at something to do: an apology, a repair, a change. If it does, do that. If it does not, the guilt has done its work and what continues is repetition.
What did the Stoics say about regret?
They treated the past as fixed and so outside our control, and regret as useful only as a guide for the present. Seneca examined his own day every evening, hid nothing from himself, and ended by pardoning himself with the instruction not to repeat it. Marcus Aurelius told himself to go back to his principles each time he failed.
Is forgiving yourself the same as excusing what you did?
No. An excuse says it was not really wrong, or not really you. Forgiveness in the sense Seneca means starts by saying exactly what was wrong and whose doing it was, and only then lets the matter rest. The standard stays. The punishment ends.