You notice you are holding a conversation in your head with somebody who is not there.

Take this situation apart. Each piece goes in one box: yours, or not yours. There is no third box, and almost nothing falls in one piece.

Sort it yourself first. Each piece goes in one box; the reasoning follows your choice.

That the conversation started without your noticing.
Not yours. Thoughts present themselves like noise from outside. That something arrives is not a decision; the Stoics blamed nobody for the first movement.
What the other person actually thinks of you.
Not yours. You do not know, and you will not find out by thinking harder. The only instrument that gives access is a question put to him.
Whether you have the conversation for real.
Yours. The imaginary version takes weeks and settles nothing; the real one takes twenty minutes and decides something. Which of the two you choose is yours.
Whether you give the other person his sharpest version in that conversation.
Yours. You are playing both parts, and you usually let him speak more cruelly than he ever did. You wrote that script.
That the subject touches you.
Not yours. That it occupies you means something is at stake that you consider important. That is information, not weakness.
Whether you notice you are doing it.
Yours. Noticing is the whole exercise. As long as it runs unnoticed it feels like thinking; the moment you see it, it is an act you can stop.
Skip and show the cut
Yours
  • Whether you give the other person his sharpest version in that conversation.You are playing both parts, and you usually let him speak more cruelly than he ever did. You wrote that script.
  • Whether you notice you are doing it.Noticing is the whole exercise. As long as it runs unnoticed it feels like thinking; the moment you see it, it is an act you can stop.
  • Whether you have the conversation for real.The imaginary version takes weeks and settles nothing; the real one takes twenty minutes and decides something. Which of the two you choose is yours.
Not yours
  • That the conversation started without your noticing.Thoughts present themselves like noise from outside. That something arrives is not a decision; the Stoics blamed nobody for the first movement.
  • What the other person actually thinks of you.You do not know, and you will not find out by thinking harder. The only instrument that gives access is a question put to him.
  • That the subject touches you.That it occupies you means something is at stake that you consider important. That is information, not weakness.
The reasoning. The inner world is the territory where almost everything is yours and where people believe that least. Of these six pieces, three sit on your side, and they are exactly the three nobody else can see: noticing, not sharpening the script, and having the conversation for real. Master those three and you do not need to master the rest.

Nearby situations

More on this topic: The inner world · How to stop overthinking

Yours, Not Yours · A Stoic practice ground · Learn · Videos · About this site · Privacy · Questions or suggestions

Free, no ads · Support with a few euros · Where it goes