You catch yourself feeling a flicker of pleasure at somebody else's setback.
Take this situation apart. Each piece goes in one box: yours, or not yours. There is no third box, and almost nothing falls in one piece.
Sort it yourself first. Each piece goes in one box; the reasoning follows your choice.
What the thought says about you.
Not yours. Nothing remarkable. Almost everybody knows this one, and noticing it suggests you are paying attention rather than that you are bad.
Whether you build it into a story in which he deserved it.
Yours. The impulse lasts a second; the story around it you construct yourself, and that is the part that sticks.
Whether you send him something kind afterwards.
Yours. Acting is the only antidote that works. One message weighs more than an hour of self-reproach and costs just as little.
Whether his setback grows or shrinks because of what you feel.
Not yours. Your mood has no influence on his week. That sounds hard and it is a relief: nothing has been done in secret.
That the thought arrived.
Not yours. Thoughts present themselves without permission. The Stoics assigned no guilt for what comes in, only for what you do with it.
Whether you name it honestly to yourself instead of pushing it away.
Yours. Pushing away does not work and makes the thought more important. Naming it removes exactly the charge the prohibition gave it.
Yours
- Whether you build it into a story in which he deserved it.The impulse lasts a second; the story around it you construct yourself, and that is the part that sticks.
- Whether you name it honestly to yourself instead of pushing it away.Pushing away does not work and makes the thought more important. Naming it removes exactly the charge the prohibition gave it.
- Whether you send him something kind afterwards.Acting is the only antidote that works. One message weighs more than an hour of self-reproach and costs just as little.
Not yours
- That the thought arrived.Thoughts present themselves without permission. The Stoics assigned no guilt for what comes in, only for what you do with it.
- What the thought says about you.Nothing remarkable. Almost everybody knows this one, and noticing it suggests you are paying attention rather than that you are bad.
- Whether his setback grows or shrinks because of what you feel.Your mood has no influence on his week. That sounds hard and it is a relief: nothing has been done in secret.
The reasoning. This is the most uncomfortable territory on the site and at the same time the clearest. Of the six pieces, three are yours, and not one of them is the thought itself. What is yours is whether you feed it, whether you name it honestly, and whether you act. The Stoics saw nothing wrong with a person having an ugly impulse; only with a person who builds his verdict on it.
- People exist for one another. Teach them, then, or bear with them.Marcus Aurelius · Meditations 8.59
Nearby situations
You wake up in a gloomy mood, with no identifiable reason.The inner worldYou catch yourself in an angry argument in your head with a boss from years ago.The inner worldAn old reproach keeps replaying in your head.The inner world
More on this topic: The inner world · How to stop overthinking