Someone tells you something in confidence and you do not know whether to pass it on.
Take this situation apart. Each piece goes in one box: yours, or not yours. There is no third box, and almost nothing falls in one piece.
Sort it yourself first. Each piece goes in one box; the reasoning follows your choice.
What is going on, and what the other person decides.
Not yours. His situation, his secret and what he does with it remain his, even now that you know. Knowing is not owning.
Your silence or your speaking.
Yours. A real weighing, not a rule. Breaking confidence is serious; staying silent while danger looms is too. Two questions help: am I serving the other person with this, or mainly my own discomfort? And can I say it to him first, before I tell anybody else?
What speaking does to your bond.
Not yours. Even with the purest weighing, the friendship can take damage; gratitude for your courage is not guaranteed. That risk belongs to the decision and cannot be planned away. You choose the deed, not the aftermath.
Yours
- Your silence or your speaking.A real weighing, not a rule. Breaking confidence is serious; staying silent while danger looms is too. Two questions help: am I serving the other person with this, or mainly my own discomfort? And can I say it to him first, before I tell anybody else?
Not yours
- What is going on, and what the other person decides.His situation, his secret and what he does with it remain his, even now that you know. Knowing is not owning.
- What speaking does to your bond.Even with the purest weighing, the friendship can take damage; gratitude for your courage is not guaranteed. That risk belongs to the decision and cannot be planned away. You choose the deed, not the aftermath.
The reasoning. The secret is his; the mouth is yours. Weigh it by asking whom you serve.
- In company, speak as little as possible about other people: neither praising, nor blaming, nor comparing.after Epictetus · Enchiridion 33
Nearby situations
A colleague breaks down during a meeting.Pity and compassionOn the street someone asks for money; you doubt whether the story is true.Pity and compassionA colleague gets torn apart in a meeting while everyone stays silent.Pity and compassion
More on this topic: Pity and compassion · How to control your emotions