A colleague breaks down during a meeting.
Take this situation apart. Each piece goes in one box: yours, or not yours. There is no third box, and almost nothing falls in one piece.
Sort it yourself first. Each piece goes in one box; the reasoning follows your choice.
Whether you get up and walk out with him.
Yours. One act of ten seconds that the whole room is waiting for and almost nobody performs. It is small, it is yours, and at that moment it is the only thing that counts.
Whether you treat him afterwards as you did before.
Yours. Most of the damage comes not from the moment but from the weeks after, in which people start being careful. Carrying on normally is a choice and the largest gift available.
What the others will say about it.
Not yours. Offices talk; that happens without you. What you yourself do not pass on is a separate matter, and that one is in the Yours column.
Whether he accepts help afterwards.
Not yours. Offering is yours, accepting is his. Anyone who measures his own usefulness by the acceptance ends up resenting somebody in trouble.
That it happens in front of everybody.
Not yours. Nobody chooses the moment at which it stops working. The room was chance, and it is the circumstance rather than his character.
Whether you ask what he needs instead of deciding what is good for him.
Yours. The question costs nothing and saves everything. What you would want in his place is rarely what he wants, and you find that difference only by asking.
Yours
- Whether you get up and walk out with him.One act of ten seconds that the whole room is waiting for and almost nobody performs. It is small, it is yours, and at that moment it is the only thing that counts.
- Whether you treat him afterwards as you did before.Most of the damage comes not from the moment but from the weeks after, in which people start being careful. Carrying on normally is a choice and the largest gift available.
- Whether you ask what he needs instead of deciding what is good for him.The question costs nothing and saves everything. What you would want in his place is rarely what he wants, and you find that difference only by asking.
Not yours
- That it happens in front of everybody.Nobody chooses the moment at which it stops working. The room was chance, and it is the circumstance rather than his character.
- Whether he accepts help afterwards.Offering is yours, accepting is his. Anyone who measures his own usefulness by the acceptance ends up resenting somebody in trouble.
- What the others will say about it.Offices talk; that happens without you. What you yourself do not pass on is a separate matter, and that one is in the Yours column.
The reasoning. Compassion runs aground in two places: people want to solve the trouble itself, and they want their help to be accepted. Both sit under Not yours. What sits under Yours is small and concrete: walking out with him, behaving normally later, asking instead of assuming. That is less than you would like to give and precisely what is needed.
- You must live for another if you wish to live for yourself.Seneca · Letters 48.2
Nearby situations
On the street someone asks for money; you doubt whether the story is true.Pity and compassionA colleague gets torn apart in a meeting while everyone stays silent.Pity and compassionA friend is in the middle of a divorce and calls you every evening.Pity and compassion
More on this topic: Pity and compassion · How to control your emotions