On the street someone asks for money; you doubt whether the story is true.
Take this situation apart. Each piece goes in one box: yours, or not yours. There is no third box, and almost nothing falls in one piece.
Sort it yourself first. Each piece goes in one box; the reasoning follows your choice.
Whether you give.
Yours. Do what fits you, and let what the other does with your gift be his part. Give or do not give, but do not let your choice be held hostage by a question nobody can answer.
Whether his story is true.
Not yours. You will never get to verify it; it lives inside him. Whoever first demands certainty about somebody else’s inside has a watertight excuse never to do anything.
What the bystanders think of you, whether you give or not.
Not yours. Whoever gives is naive to one passer-by; whoever walks on is hard to another. Both verdicts are passed on the pavement, in a second, by people who walk on themselves. Leave the jury in the street; it never had a vote anyway.
Yours
- Whether you give.Do what fits you, and let what the other does with your gift be his part. Give or do not give, but do not let your choice be held hostage by a question nobody can answer.
Not yours
- Whether his story is true.You will never get to verify it; it lives inside him. Whoever first demands certainty about somebody else’s inside has a watertight excuse never to do anything.
- What the bystanders think of you, whether you give or not.Whoever gives is naive to one passer-by; whoever walks on is hard to another. Both verdicts are passed on the pavement, in a second, by people who walk on themselves. Leave the jury in the street; it never had a vote anyway.
The reasoning. Your gift ends at the giving; what comes after was never for sale.
- Kindness is invincible, provided it is genuine and without pretense.Marcus Aurelius · Meditations 11.18
Nearby situations
A colleague gets torn apart in a meeting while everyone stays silent.Pity and compassionA friend is in the middle of a divorce and calls you every evening.Pity and compassionYour aging father refuses help he clearly needs.Pity and compassion
More on this topic: Pity and compassion · How to control your emotions