An unexpected sum of money comes your way.
Take this situation apart. Each piece goes in one box: yours, or not yours. There is no third box, and almost nothing falls in one piece.
Sort it yourself first. Each piece goes in one box; the reasoning follows your choice.
Whether you wait a month before deciding anything large.
Yours. Money coming in asks to be moved, and that is exactly the wrong moment to decide. Waiting is an act and is entirely yours.
Whether you give some of it away.
Yours. No moral obligation, but it is a test. What you can give away easily, you own; what you cannot spare, owns you.
Whether you adjust your life to it or set it beside your life.
Yours. Here is the distinction that decides everything. Spending that raises your fixed costs changes your life permanently; a one-off sum does not, unless you let it.
What others think of what you do with it.
Not yours. Somebody always turns up with an opinion and occasionally with a request. Their verdict is beyond your reach; what you tell them is not.
Whether the sum holds its value.
Not yours. Markets, interest, inflation. You can spread and you can guarantee nothing, and anyone who believes otherwise runs the largest risk.
That it falls to you.
Not yours. Inheritance, bonus, windfall. It did not arrive because you deserved it in the moral sense and it may just as well fail to arrive next time.
Yours
- Whether you wait a month before deciding anything large.Money coming in asks to be moved, and that is exactly the wrong moment to decide. Waiting is an act and is entirely yours.
- Whether you adjust your life to it or set it beside your life.Here is the distinction that decides everything. Spending that raises your fixed costs changes your life permanently; a one-off sum does not, unless you let it.
- Whether you give some of it away.No moral obligation, but it is a test. What you can give away easily, you own; what you cannot spare, owns you.
Not yours
- That it falls to you.Inheritance, bonus, windfall. It did not arrive because you deserved it in the moral sense and it may just as well fail to arrive next time.
- What others think of what you do with it.Somebody always turns up with an opinion and occasionally with a request. Their verdict is beyond your reach; what you tell them is not.
- Whether the sum holds its value.Markets, interest, inflation. You can spread and you can guarantee nothing, and anyone who believes otherwise runs the largest risk.
The reasoning. A windfall looks like luck and works like a test. The Stoics had no objection to it: money is material, neither good nor bad. What the cut makes visible is that almost everything that matters sits under Yours, and that all of it consists of decisions you could equally take a month from now. Only the hurry belongs to nobody.
- Money has never made anyone rich; on the contrary it makes everyone greedier for more.Seneca · Letters 119.9
Nearby situations
Your car unexpectedly needs a costly repair.Money and possessionsA friend who still owes you money asks for another loan.Money and possessionsA family member asks whether you will guarantee a loan.Money and possessions
More on this topic: Money and possessions · The circle of control