A family member asks whether you will guarantee a loan.

Take this situation apart. Each piece goes in one box: yours, or not yours. There is no third box, and almost nothing falls in one piece.

Sort it yourself first. Each piece goes in one box; the reasoning follows your choice.

How the family talks about it if you say no.
Not yours. A no to a guarantee sometimes becomes, around birthday tables, a no to the family. That story is written by others, with their own pen. Whoever says yes out of fear of that story pays later in money what he refused to pay now in discomfort.
Your yes or no.
Yours. A real decision, not a courtesy. Guaranteeing means being able to lose the amount without having influence over it; exactly the combination this exercise teaches you to recognise. Say yes only if you can carry the loss and the relationship can survive it.
His financial situation, and what he does with the money.
Not yours. How he got there and how it ends stays outside your sight and outside your grip; guaranteeing gives no steering wheel, only risk.
Skip and show the cut
Yours
  • Your yes or no.A real decision, not a courtesy. Guaranteeing means being able to lose the amount without having influence over it; exactly the combination this exercise teaches you to recognise. Say yes only if you can carry the loss and the relationship can survive it.
Not yours
  • His financial situation, and what he does with the money.How he got there and how it ends stays outside your sight and outside your grip; guaranteeing gives no steering wheel, only risk.
  • How the family talks about it if you say no.A no to a guarantee sometimes becomes, around birthday tables, a no to the family. That story is written by others, with their own pen. Whoever says yes out of fear of that story pays later in money what he refused to pay now in discomfort.
The reasoning. The signature is small and the box behind it is large; sign only what you can carry without looking back.

Nearby situations

More on this topic: Money and possessions · The circle of control

Yours, Not Yours · A Stoic practice ground · Learn · Videos · About this site · Privacy · Questions or suggestions

Free, no ads · Support with a few euros · Where it goes