Short video · Loss and fate

Lost something you love? Here's what's yours

A friendship ends, someone moves away, something precious is gone, and it feels as if it was taken from you. This short video looks at loss through one of Epictetus's hardest lines.

Answer first, then watch. Skip to the video

When you lose what you love, it was taken from you.
Right: false.Not quite: false. This is not a claim that loss should not hurt, or that grief is a mistake. Missing what you loved is what loving it looks like afterwards. The point is about the word ‘taken’. It assumes that what you had was owned, so that losing it is a theft. Nothing you love comes with that guarantee: not a thing, not a friendship, not a person. Keeping them is not yours. The time you had with them was.

Watch the video

34 seconds · English · Watch on YouTube

The sorting

Yours
  • How you care for them while you have them
  • How you remember them
Not yours
  • Keeping things forever
  • Whether a friendship lasts
  • How long the people you love are with you

What the video says

When you lose what you love, it was taken from you. True or false? False. It was never fully yours. It was on loan.

Things, friendships, even the people you love: keeping them forever is not yours. What is yours? How you care for them while you have them.

Epictetus taught it almost 2,000 years ago: never say ‘I have lost it’. Say ‘I have given it back’. So love what you have, while you have it.

Yours, not yours. Practise for free at yoursnotyours.com.

Beyond the video

This is not a claim that loss should not hurt, or that grief is a mistake. Missing what you loved is what loving it looks like afterwards. The point is about the word ‘taken’. It assumes that what you had was owned, so that losing it is a theft. Nothing you love comes with that guarantee: not a thing, not a friendship, not a person. Keeping them is not yours. The time you had with them was.

Epictetus put it in his blunt way: never say of anything that you have lost it, but that you have given it back. He applies it to a child and a wife as well as to property, and that sounds hard. But the line is less about the moment of loss than about the time before it. Whoever knows that something is on loan treats it differently: with more attention, and with less taken for granted.

The source

Keep practising

More short videos

Yours, Not Yours · A Stoic practice ground · Learn · Videos · About this site · Privacy · Questions or suggestions

Free, no ads · Support with a few euros · Where it goes